Guardians of Order's Mark MacKinnon Resurfaces...On Kickstarter!

Back in 2006, it all started with a post from George R.R. Martin on his website (I couldn't find an archival version but I copy/pasted it onto a blogpost here back then, and I copy part of it again now:

I regret to announce that Guardians of Order, the Canadian games company that issued the GAME OF THRONES role-playing game last fall, is closing its doors and going out of business.

Although the GoO website remains open and there is some fan activity on the message boards there, it would appear that orders are no longer being fulfilled and emails to Guardians itself are going unaswered. The company's office has been vacated, and the company phone has been disconnected, When I finally reached GoO's owner and president Mark MacKinnon last week, he confirmed what many had come to suspect -- that he is shutting down operations. MacKinnon is presently attempting to place some of GoO's games with other companies.

Interestingly, at the time, the speculation was that Mongoose would end up with Guardians properties (a little known fact is that Mongoose white knighted the publication Guardians last few books before White Wolf stepped in to help with the Game of Thrones and BESM 3e games). We all know now that White Wolf ended up owning the properties.

MacKinnon followed up with a classy post on the (now defunct) Guardians of Order website:

First, an apology. I am terribly sorry that George Martin broke the news about our situation. That is certainly not how I wanted the information to be released, and I had thought that my frank conversation with him about A Game of Thrones-specific issues was in confidence. This is the second time now that someone other than me releases very important news about Guardians Of Order, which leaves me frantically trying to patch the holes. The polite and proper thing for me -- as President of the company -- to do would be to contact all of our creditors (which includes some great freelancers and industry associates) FIRST and explain the situation to them. I was working on that process when my efforts were derailed by one simple website post. So I am very sorry that someone else took it upon himself to release this information. It's not how I was proceeding to handle things.

The archive is also non-existent but (with forethought) I also copy/pasted MacKinnon's post onto a blog post. I also did an extended blogpost that archived a timeline of the blowup and meltdown. Updated:Thanks to +Eric Franklin I have a link to the Guardians LiveJournal (which has some interesting things to show). We probably shouldn't be surprised if this suddenly disappears.

It also came to light a year or so ago (over in a thread on RPGNet) that MacKinnon had not only failed to pay freelancers for a number of the final http://guardiansorder.livejournal.com/ products, and had stiffed publishers in the company's Magnum Opus program, but he had also kept PDFs up on the OneBookshelf site that he no longer had the rights to sell. Unfortunately I do not have a link and the RPGNet site is notoriously hard to search. If someone can find a link to this, plese let me know in the comments here, or over on G+, and I will put the link up in this post. Updated: I found the thread wherein it was discovered that MacKinnon had been selling the PDFs (including licensed anime properties that he no longer held the license).

Now, MacKinnon has resurfaced, with a project for a board game called Upon A Fable over on Kickstarter. He even uses shots of games that freelancers never received payment for in the video on the project page. Some have called for funds raised from the Kickstarter be used to to pay back those who were never paid. I doubt there's any legal recourse, since Guardians is long gone and I am sure that they held the debt rather than MacKinnon directly, and I'm not going to assert moral recourse in this case. My reasoning for posting all of this is so that people can be informed and, hopefully, not throw good money down a deep, dark hole. This is someone who has already demonstrated a willingness to take money from a number of sources, not pay the people who have done the work and ignore communications before disappearing.

There are also a few red flags with this project. This isn't the first time this project was attempted on Kickstarter. According to a post over on the Board Game Geek site, made back in March:

This game marks my first published design in over seven years ... and I made a critical mistake. I assumed that a professional Kickstarter campaign presentation, combined with attractive graphic design and engaging game mechanics, would be sufficient to reach my Kickstarter funding target. How wrong I was. Within the first 48 hours of the campaign, I knew the funding attempt would fail; shortly thereafter, I made the decision to cancel the campaign.

It is interesting that you cannot find the original project, and that the BGG posts don't actually list MacKinnon by name. According to some emails I've read, posts on BGG threads asking about the previous non-payment to freelancers have been deleted from the site.  Also, there was a quote from their Facebook page that came to me in my email that said:

With our reworked pledge plans we are also in the position to lower our funding goal to $25,000 from $30,000. Although our costs to proceed with the project will exceed $30,000 -- printing high-quality board games is expensive! -- we are backing Upon a Fable with some of our own money as well since we will selling additional copies through retail store channels as well. Any profit to be made will be on those back-end sales and not just by meeting our minimum Kickstarter funding goal. We want to give Upon a Fable the best chance to succeed, which is why we settled on the $25,000 target.

Undercharging for a project is never a good sign that the people will be able to deliver on the project. They are already in a hole on funds, and should something unexpected happen...they will be even further in the hole. The email gave this link, but when I followed it I couldn't find the exact passage. I may just be blind. Updated: I am blind. It turns out that the above quoted bit came from an April 11th update to the Dyskami Publishing Facebook page.

Hopefully people will read all of this, follow the links and read a bit of the history before deciding to put their money on something like this.

ArtHaus Acquires Big Eyes, Small Mouth RPG

I'm not overly surprised by the news, not since I saw that some of the Guardians of Order BESM-related properties had been transferred to Arthaus on the DriveThruRPG.com website. I had hoped that it would be Mongoose who ended up with this, bu it would appear not to be the case.

Regardless, it is good news for BESM fans. I wish that it had been released as a softcover, at least, though. That price is a bit too rich for my tastes.

ArtHaus Acquires Big Eyes, Small Mouth RPG

Fans of Big Eyes, Small Mouth (BESM) will be thrilled to learn that the 3rd Edition of this award winning role playing game will be released by ArtHaus in January 2007.

Previously published by Guardians of Order, BESM is designed to be a multi-genre anime and manga game and can accommodate nearly any setting or time period. The rules are simple to use and thus do not include an overwhelming amount of specific detail, with the task resolution system and combat engine designed to capture the fast-moving nature of anime and manga action. This element is one of the central strengths of the game, making BESM ideal for either the novice or experienced role-player.

The Official Word -- The End of Guardians of Order

I'm sure that this is old news by now out in the blogosphere, but here you go:

My gods, I have no idea where to begin.

Yes ... effective more-or-less immediately, Guardians Of Order has ceased operations.

First, an apology. I am terribly sorry that George Martin broke the news about our situation. That is certainly not how I wanted the information to be released, and I had thought that my frank conversation with him about A Game of Thrones-specific issues was in confidence. This is the second time now that someone other than me releases very important news about Guardians Of Order, which leaves me frantically trying to patch the holes. The polite and proper thing for me -- as President of the company -- to do would be to contact all of our creditors (which includes some great freelancers and industry associates) FIRST and explain the situation to them. I was working on that process when my efforts were derailed by one simple website post. So I am very sorry that someone else took it upon himself to release this information. It's not how I was proceeding to handle things.

But yes, the end result is the same. GoO is no longer.

This was a very sad decision that I had to make, but it wasn't really a difficult one when I took a long, hard look at the facts. The company simply accumulated too much debt, with little hope of paying it off within the next decade, and my recent plans to get the company back in shape didn't materialise. When I kept my emotions in check and simply analysed the facts of the company's financial forecast, the only course of action was very clear. There were a combination of factors that contributed to the ultimate inability of the company to maintain fiscal health (which I have outlined several times in other posts over the years) -- the extreme softening of the RPG sales market, the drastic shift in USD/CDN exchange rates, etc -- but external circumstances are not entirely to blame. Simply put, I did not have the business acumen to run the company profitably when the going got tough. I'm going to steal a John Nephew analogy for a brief explanation.

I've been driving down the gaming industry highway in my GoOmobile since 1997, with a coffee in the cup holder and a muffin on the passenger's seat. For many years of driving, the highway was a straight path with very little traffic on it. Consequently, if I swerved a little as I ate my breakfast while driving, it wasn't a big deal ... the situations on the road were very forgiving and it was easy to keep on driving. Unfortunately, when the road started getting very crowded around 2003 and started making many twists and turns, I didn't have the foresight to put down the coffee and muffin, place both hands firmly on the wheel, and pay very close attention to the road. I just kept on driving like before, assuming everything was the same. Ultimately, the GoOmobile swerved into the path of an incredibly powerful semi-truck called "Exchange Rate Fluxuation," causing a terrible wreck and writing off the vehicle.

I'm not making light of the situation, but I thought that John's analogy was a perfect fit. Running the company when things were peachy was easy, but I faltered when the going got tough. For my lack of knowledge and experience, I sincerely apologise to our many thousands of consumers and fans, our creditors and freelancers, and to my many friends who put their faith in my dream. I failed, and I'm sorry I couldn't do better.

So where does that leave things now? I don't have all the answers yet -- I was trying to line them up before making this announcement -- but here's what I can say at this time:

• BESM Third Edition is finished and ready for press. Another company will be publishing it and providing future support. It's the most elegant version of BESM and the Tri-Stat System that I have put together and am very proud of it. If you pre-ordered the book from us, more information will follow.
• Advanced d20 Magic is back from press and will be hitting stores in August. Customers who pre-ordered directly from us will be receiving their orders.
• We are still attempting to place the A Game of Thrones RPG with another company. Of course, this requires GRRM's approval and we are still working out details. AGOT is a fantastic game, and we will do our best to see it continued.
• All outstanding orders will be fulfilled. If we are unable to ship you the order for some reason, you will have the option of having a refund sent to you. We are no longer taking any orders directly from our web store.
• Our products will remain for sale as both print books and PDFs as long as the stores will carry them. We are arranging for our products to be transferred to another company. I have no information regarding their future publication.
• Our Tri-Stat/brand licenses remain in effect for as long as indicated in the contracts, and licensees may still publish products under the terms of such licenses. Obviously, the Magnum Opus imprint will cease to operate.
• Our creditors (which includes freelancers and friendly investors) will be contacted directly in the coming weeks. There is still much to do on this end, and I ask for your patience while we get things in order and communicate with you.

Some people have inquired about my personal future, so I'll be brief. I am leaving the gaming industry. I need to concentrate on recovering financially from the collapse of the company and on rebuilding the strength of my family, which unfortunately suffered over the past couple of years. I am now working as a real estate sales representative in Guelph, and find the work a refreshing change of pace. My health is great, my family is very understanding, and I look forward to what the future will hold.

There are so many people to whom I am grateful for all their help, advice, and support over our 9-year run. Please forgive me if I forget anyone:

• my wonderful wife, Karen, for ... well ... everything
• my parents for always giving me their best wishes and telling me how proud they are of my accomplishments
• Adam Jury, who stuck with the company and with me until the end
• Jesse Scoble, for sharing so very many awesome experiences under the guise of "work"
• Jeff Mackintosh, for accepting that job offer initiated in the Columbus bar
• David Pulver, for putting BESM 2e on the map
• Ryan Dancey, for always being just a phone call away; sweet, dude
• John Zinser, for showing and mentoring me in the Hard Way
• Cindy Rice, for befriending this little guy in New York many years ago
• John and Michelle Nephew, for keen insight, support, and friendship
• Alex Fennel, for working with this fellow foreigner for several years
• Joe Saul, for always shooting straight and giving me the US perspective
• Erick Wujcik, for giving me the opportunity to carry the torch, even if I couldn't follow through
• Derek, who offered to help an old friend in need
• Andy, Todd, Jules, Lindsey, Ken, John, and Lowell for lending a helping hand
• Steve, for helping make deals happen
• The Hero Games crew, for making advertising a lot of fun
• Marcelo Figueroa, for his eternal offers of assistance; and of course
• our customers, fans, and supporters -- without whom running Guardians Of Order would have been impossible. You have my sincerest gratitude.

Hello and goodbye, as always.

Mark C. MacKinnon
President, Guardians Of Order, Inc.
Guelph, Ontario
July 31st, 2006

I guess we'll see what the next step is and who the mystery publisher is who will be taking over BESM. I am sort of hoping Mongoose, I'm not sure why of that but that's what I'm thinking/hoping. Maybe its because I would hope that Mongoose would open the system making it easier to support if you're 3rd party. It will be interesting to see what happens next.

I'm not going to put up a link to the GoO site because, who knows when it will go away now. Here is a link to a mega post that I strung together when the news of GoO's hardships first started to leak out. It may put some perspective on things.

Guardians of Order - Closed

Well, I don't think that it is a surprise but it is still sad that it has come to pass. This is from George R.R. Martin's website. I think its a shame that the news didn't come from Mark officially, but it shouldn't be a big shock at this point.

I know that Mongoose has long been interested in Tri-Stat/BESM and that they have been talking to some of the Magnum Opus publishers. Only time will tell. For fans of BESM and the Tri-Stat systems, I hope that this will mean a happy ending.

News -- George R.R. Martin

I regret to announce that Guardians of Order, the Canadian games company that issued the GAME OF THRONES role-playing game last fall, is closing its doors and going out of business.

Although the GoO website remains open and there is some fan activity on the message boards there, it would appear that orders are no longer being fulfilled and emails to Guardians itself are going unaswered. The company's office has been vacated, and the company phone has been disconnected, When I finally reached GoO's owner and president Mark MacKinnon last week, he confirmed what many had come to suspect -- that he is shutting down operations. MacKinnon is presently attempting to place some of GoO's games with other companies.

I am not privy to all of the details of how and why Guardians is going under, but I do know the company's finances were very badly affected by the decline in the value of the American dollar against the Canadian dollar. Most of GoO's sales were in the United States, so a weaker dollar meant less money coming in. The massive and gorgeous GAME OF THRONES role-playing book, four years in the making, was finally released last November (for details, see the news stories in my archives) and appears to have sold quite well, but its success proved too little and too late to save Guardians of Order.

I am presently attempting to work out some sort of settlement with Guardians that would allow the RPG to continue with another company, but at this writing the future of the game (if any) remains unresolved.

Ironically, this announcement comes just as the GAME OF THRONES RPG has been nominated for four 'ENie' awards as one of the best games of 2005. The game has been nominated in the categories of Best Production Values, Best d20/ OGL Product, Best Product, and Best Game. If you're a fan of the game and would like to cast a ballot, voting is open until July 30 at http://www.enworld.org/ennies/voting.php

Blogs really aren't supposed to be edited (well, if you are in the Rebecca Blood school of blogging) but I decided to link to this thread on the Mongoose Publishing forums which may cast some light on who might end up with some of the pieces of Guardians of Order. Although if you haven't figured out who I'm talking about by now I would be greatly shocked and surprised.

I return you now to your regularly scheduled Dorkland!

Guardians of Order: And Then There Was One

Latest Update: This is the message from Mark MacKinnion (president of Guardians of Order), posted on various email lists and websites. Personally, I am not very impressed. I think that Mark took too long to post this message, which isn't unusual for the company quite frankly, and I really don't like the BUY, BUY, BUY! approach that they seem to be taking. I think that the company needs (and has needed) to work better with fan base. This is a two-way street after all. You have to give if you want to get.

Yes, I was the one asking for eratta on their web forum. I don't think that expecting a company to live up to a promise made in July is expecting too much from them. This, of course, isn't the only thing. There have been cases of rudeness from (former) staffers on email lists and on their web forums. THAT isn't all that unusual in this industry, but it really doesn't take much to turn fans away. I agree that Guardians of Order needs their fans to stand behind them and try to turn this around, but are they going to stand behind their fans as well?

All of the previous material is still in this posting, just scroll down.

[EDITED (3 Jan 05): While I was originally going to post this message on New Year's Eve, the recent tragedy in Asia gave me pause. I didn't think it was the right time, given the magnitude of the pain and

suffering that makes our woes seem so very insignificant in comparison. That said, certain information, and mis-information, leaked today to the gaming community today, and I owe it to our supporters to respond quickly. This address, plus the explanation on our Enlightened Self Interest page, should put most things in the correct context.]

On this uncharacteristically warm New Year's Eve I sit at my computer desk sipping hot chocolate as the sweet sounds of Bach's Violin Partita in B minor plays in the background. I am thankful that all is well in our great country, and mourn the terrible losses that have devastated many families in Asia after the earthquake and tsunami. We are witnessing the incredible power of Nature, and I cannot help but be humbled.

Thinking about GoO's 2004 business year, I am proud of what we accomplished but also disappointed with what could have been. A few key products needed to be delayed for various reasons, which unfortunately turned 2004 into our "year of sequels" (with sequels, conversions, and revisions) rather than our "year of new products." Throw a weak economy into the mix, and it can be a recipe for disaster. Faith manages, though, and we pulled through. But sometimes … faith needs a little help.

SUMMARY OF 2004
To recap the developments at Guardians Of Order in 2004:

* we released our two largest books ever, both weighing in at 352 pages: Ex Machina: Tri-Stat Cyberpunk Genre and The Authority RPG and Resource Book
* a plethora of licensed BESM/BESM d20 anime guides (9 guides, plus Slayers d20) made it to market and finished many of our series
* we released BESM d20 Revised edition — updated to d20 v3.5 — only to learn to our embarrassment that it actually wasn't updated
* we reprinted BESM d20 Revised, and made sure it was updated this time!
* we converted and re-released several of our popular BESM Tri-Stat titles to the BESM d20 system
* working with the fine gents at Hero Games, we co-published Reality Storm: When Worlds Collide, a crossover adventure and conversions book featuring the characters from our Silver Age Sentinels and Hero Games' Champions
* we announced the acquisition of an RPG/fan guide license for the cult-hit anime series, Neon Genesis Evangelion
* we moved and expanded our PDF offerings to DriveThruRPG.com, experiencing greater-than-expected sales in this new venture
* we finalised our deal with Erick Wujcik of Phage Press to continue offering sales of Amber DRPG-related merchandise, with the hopes of more to come in the future
* we helped two Magnum Opus publishers bring their "great works" to print: Hearts Swords Flowers and Everstone – Blood Legacy
* we released our critically acclaimed short story anthology sequel, Path of the Bold, set in the Empire City superhero universe
* we announced plans for BESM Third Edition, to release in spring/summer 2005

In total, we released 24 products -- 23 books of our own and one co-publication with Hero Games -- in 2004, effectively matching 2003's releases. Breaking down the products into lines, we have:
* Silver Age Sentinels/superhero books: 4 (17%)
* BESM/BESM d20/anime books (original): 7 (29%)
* Anime books (licensed): 10 (42%)
* Other: 3 (12%)
As you can see, nearly three-quarters of our output involved original or licensed anime material -- our signature strength. If I had to pick just a few must-buy stellar highlights, I'd recommend Ex Machina, The Authority RPG, Slayers d20, d20 Military Vehicles, and Path of the Bold.

SALES AND RPGs
I have talked to company presidents, renowned retailers, distributor representatives, and industry gurus. If there is one thing they all agreed on in 2004, it is the remarkable downturn in role-playing game sales. I'm sure the reasoning behind this trend is complex and varied, but the final result cannot be argued: RPGs were seriously hurt this past year.

Clearly, as an RPG-only company, this should have devastated our sales income, right? Well, no, actually. For the third consecutive year, Guardians Of Order has enjoyed an increase in gross sales revenue, and we achieved this remarkable fact without A Game of Thrones RPG (which, unfortunately, is delayed until spring/summer 2005). I'll admit that releasing larger and more expensive books accounted for much of this increase, but it is still a great accomplishment for us in a declining marketplace.

Why, then, is our net income the lowest it has ever been?

LARGER THAN RPGs -- THE SLIDING US DOLLAR
To put it bluntly, over the past two years the American dollar has had the snot kicked out of it by all major foreign currencies. Unfortunately, this includes the Canadian dollar and as an exporting company that calls the Great White North home, we've been hit hard. Really hard. We pay most of our fixed expenses (company overhead, such as salaries and rent) in Canadian dollars, which means that we must convert our US dollar revenue into Canadian funds for disbursement. One American dollar used to fetch $1.60 Canadian a few years back when the US economy was stronger, but the continual decline for two years has dropped that to about $1.15 -- a loss of nearly 30%. This "exchange rate deficit" comes directly out of our bottom line, and has resulted in us losing nearly a quarter million (Canadian) dollars since the start of the decline.

There is no end in sight for the weak US dollar, and so our business plan is forced to adapt through downsizing and cost-cutting. There comes a time when you have to say "that's enough."

A PLEA FOR ASSISTANCE
Although we are firmly dedicated to having a full release schedule in 2005, we can't do it alone. We have an abundance of inventory in our warehouse -- partially the result of low sales, and partially due to greater-than-expected book trade returns -- and we need to convert a large portion of it to cash quickly and efficiently.

Starting today, we are launching what we're calling an "Enlightened Self Interest" sales campaign to help us convert inventory into cash (http://www.guardiansorder.com/2005). If there's a book you've been thinking about buying from us, but have been waiting for the "right time" … well, now is most certainly the "right time." The page also has a few older gems for sale, but copies are extremely limited. We have many books waiting in the wings, but the company needs an influx of revenue to remain healthy. Please take a moment and visit our Save GoO webpage for more information.

This New Year's Eve message is about looking back and look forward. I don't want to dwell in the doom and gloom, but every bit of support helps. The sky isn't falling … at least not yet.

REVIEW OF GoO IN 2004
Although we have been under tremendous strain over the past year, I think we still did excellent work. Briefly, here is my review of our company's performance in 2004:

Communication: B-
- With all the tools at our disposal -- message boards, mailing lists, website, and a weblog -- we should be able to communicate frequently and efficiently with our gaming community. Unfortunately, many hours of my time must be spent on financial management (budgeting carefully and moving monies from place to place) each week, which has prevented us from keeping in touch.
Effort: A-
- Not everything worked out as planned this past year, but we collectively worked very hard under difficult circumstances.
Follow-through: B
- We worked through a lot of backlog in 2004 (BESM Space Fantasy, Fushigi Yugi and Hellsing fan guides, SAS supplements), but due to many unfortunate circumstances Tekumel and A Game of Thrones RPG have still not yet made it to press. Tekumel is finally approved, though, so we are very, very close; AGOT is also well on its way, with a March 2005 release planned for the Deluxe Limited Edition.
Innovation and Leadership: C
- Unfortunately, "leading" took a backseat to "producing" in 2004. Although we had a few highlights -- Ex Machina and The Authority RPG in particular -- we'll pick up this ball again in 2005.
Quality: A
- We produced simply amazing stuff in 2004. This would have been an A+ if not for the unfortunate error in BESM d20 Revised Edition.
Overall Analysis: B-
- Although I had hoped to rate my company better this year, it was not to be. I think we stumbled in 2004. Not terribly, but it happened. I think we can turn that around in 2005 if plans hold.

THE CRYSTAL BALL OF 2005
The future is always a tricky thing in this industry. You don't want to announce many ideas too early, for fear you can't follow through in time or that someone else will beat you to the punch. At the same time, fans want to know what you have planned and announcing plans early builds hype. This year, I've decided to lay the cards on the table and give you insights into our future:

EARLY 2005
* Tekumel: Empire of the Petal Throne -- The long-awaited RPG based on M.A.R. Barker's exciting world is approved and ready for press.
* Dreaming Cities: Tri-Stat Urban Fantasy Genre -- As the follow up to the new-wave cyberpunk book, Ex Machina, there are high expectations for this book. With a complete Tri-Stat dX rule set and three world settings, you won't be disappointed.
* BESM Revolutionary Girl Utena (Book 3) -- This book is ready for press, but low pre-orders are holding it back briefly.
* BESM d20 Monstrous Manual -- Adam is laying the book out now, with art soon to follow. It's a balanced point-based breakdown of over 100 fantasy monsters, each of which is given an "anime spin."
* Advanced d20 Magic -- Featuring the alternate DC-based magic spell system that premiered in Slayers d20, this book is ready for layout. Unfortunately, there are many products at the layout stage, and we still have to prioritise everything. Still, it should be out shortly.
* The Shroud -- This first supplement for the Everstone RPG explores the world of Lannith and the swamp-like forest of The Shroud.

SPRING 2005
* A Game of Thrones RPG Deluxe Limited Edition -- A masterpiece two-years in the making, and we are so very close now. With over 450 full-colour pages and an art budget of $30,000, this is destined to be one of most gorgeous RPGs ever published. Throw in excellent writing and game design (for both d20 and Tri-Stat), and the result will be truly stunning indeed. Signed and numbered editions are available for pre-order now.
* BESM Neon Genesis Evangelion Books 1 and 2 -- At last, the fan-favourite anime series will receive the BESM treatment. Your campaign will never be the same again!
* Big Eyes, Small Mouth Anime Card Game -- Our first card game published under the GoO brand, this is an exciting Hearts variant that is easy to learn but difficult to master.
* Ex Machina: d20 Cyberpunk Genre -- A d20 version of our cyberpunk masterpiece, containing core rules and four complete game settings.
* Tekumel: d20 System RPG -- The glory of Tekumel, detailing a customised d20 mechanic and the expansive world setting.
* Dreaming Cities: d20 Urban Fantasy Genre -- Three urban fantasy world settings, wrapped in customised d20 mechanics.

SUMMER 2005
* A Game of Thrones d20 -- Westerosi politics blend perfectly with a gritty d20 mechanic to create the best in d20 role-playing. This standard edition will be a gorgeous full-colour hardcover.
* BESM Third Edition -- We return to our flagship product in 2005 with a new edition, featuring the new roll-high Tri-Stat implementation and a detailed multi-genre campaign setting that spans infinite dimensions. One system to rule them all!
* A Game of Thrones: The Book of Ice and Fire RPG -- This core rulebook for the Tri-Stat System gives you everything you need in one place for the ultimate "A Song of Ice and Fire" campaign.
* BESM Companion: The Player's Guide to the Multiverse -- Everything you wanted to know about the BESM Multiverse is here, along with templates to complement any character.

LATER 2005
I don't want to give away too many details, but a number of products are planned for later in the year. Here is a partial list, edited to remove my secret surprises:
* BESM Player's Options -- A book of rule variants
* Winter is Coming -- A companion book to A Game of Thrones core rulebook(s)
* The Authority Companion -- Covers Millar's run on The Authority comic
* A Clash of Kings -- Expands upon Martin's world, covering the second novel in his series

THANK YOU, AND GOODNIGHT
That wraps up this address of 2004 … a bittersweet reflection of what was, and what could have been. With a strong release schedule planned for next year, I predict that 2005 will be the fourth year in a row in which we see increased sales. It will be a tremendous year for me personally as well, for my wife and I are expecting my second son to arrive in mid-January.

If you enjoy the products we create, and want to see us continue in our mission, please consider purchasing a book or two today from your local retailer or our webstore (http://www.guardiansorder.com/store). Additionally, you would not believe how much good press (reviews, discussion threads, telling your local retailer what you think of our stuff, etc.) helps. We need your support now more than ever.

Thanks for reading, and best wishes for the new year!

Mark C. MacKinnon
President
Guardians Of Order, Inc.
http://www.guardiansorder.com

NOTE: This message may be reposted to other internet sites and distributed freely.

Update 10:00 pm EST: Before going to bed... While this isn't substantiated, it would appear that the powers that be at GoO informed freelancers roughly a month ago (I am sure to figure out plans for making good on debts), however lisencees (it would seem those who were planning on publishing through Guardian's Magnum Opus line) were not notified, some only finding out through the various internet forums.

Update 7:45 pm EST: Apparently the Livejournal entry by Jeff Mackintosh has been marked as viewable only by those logged into LJ. Now I wish that I had put more of the entry onto this blog entry. I will look for cached versions and update, if possible.

Just a few minutes later, now Livejournal is saying that there is no such entry.

Update 8:45 pm EST: Turns out that I should have just looked in my other open window. I hadn't closed the original window that I opened with Jeff's posting. Since this seems to have been taken down. I'm sorry to hear that this has happened, but I do think that the information should be out there. This isn't an indictment of GoO, it is unfortunate that this isn't the best of economies, and when the economy goes bad businesses some times have to close. That isn't what I would want to happen with GoO.

Update 8:53 pm EST: Appatently all of those journalism classes in high school and college are amounting to something. And people say that blogs AREN'T the future of journalism. Jeff mackintosh has posted a retraction on his LJ. If you scroll down you will also find the complete text of his original posting. All of this seems like a case of trying to put the genie back into the bottle.

Needless to say, this is something that will be followed by this blog.

"There seems to be a huge amount of confusion, which is entirely my own damn fault for poorly wording some elements of my previous post. Chalk any confusion to me being in a very dark mood and thus being melodramatic and unclear in my choice of words and phrase. Due to the confusion, I'm removing my previous post to avoid the incorrect message getting out there (which is locking the barn door after the horse has been stolen - the wrong message has already gotten out there...) - my post was a casual post that I thought would be read only by friends who know me better than the complete strangers who have come by and read my journal. I'm surprised at the number of people who came by to read my journal...

"Anyhow, as I said in the post, official word is coming later this week that will explain things in greater detail."

Canada's Guardians of Order (producers of BESM, Silver Age Sentinels, the upcoming A Game of Thrones RPG and many other anime and other licensed RPGs) is now a company of one. How will this effect the company's ability to meet their production schedule? Only time will be able to tell. According to GoO's discussion forums, Guardians of Order owner Mark MacKinnon is quoted as saying "Sorry to rain on the doomsday parade, but to quote a very smart little chicken 'the sky is not falling.'" Whether or not this is true, only time will be able to tell.

RPG.net, that bastion of unbiased reporting has spawned a thread of considerable size.

whisper_jeff: The Big News The original link to the now non-existant posting has been removed (even though it is still in the title)

"Ok, some of you may know this already but with the New Year now into it's third day, I figured it's time to talk about it openly. Official word has not yet been announced but I expect that to happen some time very soon this week.

"I am unemployed.

"As of the end of November, I was laid off from Guardians of Order. For a variety of reasons (that I will probably take the time discuss at some point later in greater detail), the biggest of which was a drastically tanking exchange rate, the company has been forced to downsize to just Mark. For the third year in a row, our sales went up yet the exchange rate has declined so drastically over the last two years, it's amounted to almost a quarter million dollar decline in income. For a company our size, that simply became too much to swallow.

"Rather than continue to attempt to run the company and just wait for the house of cards to come crashing down, we decided that it was best to exit gracefully. That meant downsizing the company (to slash overhead) and making every effort to publish what we currently have in production so that 1) our fans could get the books they've been waiting for and, more importantly, 2) we could generate the revenue so that our debts can be paid off (in other words, if you've ever thought about buying a Guardians of Order product, now is a really good time to do so). We do not want to leave a swath of unpaid debts behind us so we've made and are continuing to make every effort to exit correctly.

"Does that mean you're going to see Tekumel and Game of Thrones and that other product you've been looking forward to? Yup. Absolutely. We (in the sense of Guardians of Order) are still planning on publishing them. And many other products. The company will just publish them with only Mark as staff. The rest of us will not be with the company. With overhead slashed, the profits from the books published will be higher and thus we will be able to pay our debts. We aren't walking away from this all - we're trying to close shop properly.

"Does that mean that you, Mr/Ms freelancer are still going to get paid for the hard work you did for us? Yup. You might get paid a bit late and we ask for your understanding, but we are committed to ensuring all our debts, especially those to freelancers, get paid. That's why we're publishing our final run of products. That's why we've done everything we can to do this right. This entire situation sucks fucking ass, but we're trying to do it in a way that screws as few people as humanly possible (ideally none...).

"Now, more personally, what does this mean for me?

"Will I be able to get another job in the industry? Well, I've already turned down one job in the industry. It was a hard decision. A damn hard decision (a company I like run by people I like working on projects I like...), but the reality is I need to start planning for my future and thus I need to stop selling myself short. I have a market value and I would now like to earn something closer to that value and few companies in the game industry can afford to pay me near that value. Thus, it is highly unlikely that I will remain in the game industry. I don't want to leave. Quite the contrary - I've invested over a decade of my life into this industry and I would love to stay here, but I have a salary expectation now and I can think of only a handful of game companies that could reach that number... Thus, I suspect I'll leave the industry with my next job.

"What do I want to do? I'd love to get into video games. That's my first hope. I doubt I'll be able to - it's a competitive market and, right now, it's an employer's market, not an employee's - there are more highly qualified people looking than jobs available, by far. Thus, I expect it to be difficult for me to get into a video game company but I will be making the effort since that would be an ideal industry for me - I would be able to apply the skills I have in an industry that can pay what I am worth.

"Since that's unlikely, odds are far more likely that I'll join a design studio or some corporate position. Not my first passion but, right now I'm Cuba in Jerry Maguire.

"Am I moving? I was seriously thinking about moving to Toronto but, I've realized, it's stupid for me to move until I know where my next job will be. Moving is never fun so moving twice would be less so. Also, while moving in with a roommate might cut my month-to-month costs, moving isn't cheap - I'll probably break even by staying in Guelph until I find my next job. Thus, until I know where my next job will be, I'm staying put. I hate Guelph but it'd be stupid for me to move out of Guelph just for the sake of moving...

"Will I be ok? Yeah. I am sure I'll be fine in the end and, with any luck, in an even better position. Right now, I'm depressed in a big way. This sort of thing is a major kick in the ego... Intellectually, I know things will be fine and it'll take some time to find my next job but I've got that time available. I know things could be so much worse (tsunami anyone?). Intellectually, I know all of that stuff and it's that intellectual knowledge that allows me to get through the emotional thought process. Which is that I'm a big fucking failure and I suck. Yeah, I know I'm not, but try telling my emotional thought process that - it isn't listening to me even though I'm sure I know better... It's really too bad that the intellectual and emotional minds rarely agree on things... Mind you, maybe it's better, at this point, that they do disagree... Imagine if they both thought I sucked... :)

"Anyhow, there's the big news. If you have questions, ask. The above should cover most of the key details, however. Really, it boils down to this - Guardians of Order was going to fail and we had an option - fail spectacularly and suddenly when the house of cards came crashing down or exit in a way that allowed us to publish everything we wanted to publish and pay off all the debts we needed to pay off. The choice seems pretty obvious, if you have a shred of humanity... It sucks for me, but I can at least look at myself in the mirror knowing that I did what I could to ensure we did things right...

"So, yeah, if I've seemed out of sorts of late, you now know why."

Edited 7:05 pm EST