I meant to talk about these a couple of weeks ago, but with all the
Gen Con prep, they sort of fell through the cracks here at the blog. If it isn't apparent yet, I'm a huge fan of
Doctor Who, started watching the classic series as a kid on
PBS, and then carried over to the new stuff. It isn't a popular position amongst older
Who fans, but Matt Smith grew into the role and became one of my favorite Doctors (never surpassing Jon Pertwee, however).
As you may or may not know, the comic license for
Doctor Who recently changed hands, now being possessed by the British publisher
Titan Comics. I've reviewed a few
Titan books here and there on the blog, and if you look around you can find some of my reiviews. They do good books.
I had good expectations that they would do some good
Doctor Who books as well. I was right.
Both of these first issues felt like they could have been episodes of their respective Doctors' television runs.
The 10th Doctor issue was mostly set up of the situation, and introduction of Gabriella, a first generation Mexican-American, the next Companion. I'm sure that it was intentional, attempting to create an echo of previous Companions, but the Doctor's first words to Gabriella in the story are almost exactly the same as when the 9th Doctor first met Rose. I thought that was a nice touch.
The setup is that there are some supernatural shenanigans going on around The Day of the Dead in present Day Brooklyn. Being that it is
Doctor Who, I am assuming that the supernatural veneer will be debunked for something more alien, but it is still a good story. I am guessing that this is the 10th Doctor after the events of the Anniversary Special, but I could be wrong. Those few quiet moments we get with the Doctor in the issue seem to hint to that to me.
However, the high point of this issue has to be the art of Elena Casagrande. She brings a indie comic, personality-based approach that brings the characters to life and reminds me a lot of the work of Ming Doyle. This is an artist to watch in the years to come.
With the first issue of the 11th Doctor's comic we get a similar approach as in the 10th Doctor's. We get an introduction to the world of the person who will be the Companion, in this case Alice Obiefune, a Londoner. When the alieness breaks into her world, we see the differences immediately between the 10th and 11th Doctors. The comic captures the manic quality of the 11th very well. All in all, I think that both of these first episodes manage to capture the qualities of their Doctors well.
The 11th Doctor is kind, sympathetic and as empathetic as his alien nature allows him to be. For him, how Alice is feeling is just as important as the alien stuff that is happening in the city, if not more important. He takes time to talk with her about her mother, rather than chase down the alien. All because he thought that she was sad.
One of the reasons that I liked Matt Smith's portrayal of the Doctor was that his character was this juxtaposition of weird alien not quite getting it with a strong empathy for those around him. Where other Doctors were drawn into situations to win, he honestly wants to try to help. Unfortunately the Doctor getting involved in a situation isn't always helps. This dichotomy drives not only this incarnation of the Doctor, but also many of the stories that he is a part of as well.
How does the "man" who needs to help deal with his very existence often making things worse?
I enjoyed these comics. To be honest, I don't have a lot of a background with previous
Doctor Who comics. I read a few of the
IDW Publishing era issue, and I've seen a few of the classic stories from the
Marvel Comics era, but this is my first time getting in on the ground floor of things. I very much enjoyed these comics. Both issues encapsulated what I liked about the respective Doctors and did a good job of feeling like episodes of the show.
The art is the 11th Doctor comic moved effortlessly between realistic and "cartoony" (for lack of a better word), as the story needed it. This flexibility of the art is also what gives the story much of its impact. Artist Simon Fraser should get props for the power of his art bringing so much to this story.
Should you buy these comics? I would say that picking up these comics are a necessity for any
Doctor Who loving comic fan. If, like me, you've never regularly picked up a
Doctor Who comic, now is your chance.
As a fan of roleplaying, it is a shame that we can't see synergy between the various licensors, I would love to see writeups for the
Doctor Who game from
Cubicle 7 of the various characters appearing in the comics.
